Appalachian League Collateral Damage Bad For Baseball
According to Baseball America, Major League Baseball is considering eliminating 25 percent of Minor League baseball for a number of reasons including the need to pay players a living wage. Part of that is the elimination of stateside short season minor league baseball.
For the Mets, that means no Kingsport Mets or Brooklyn Cyclones. With respect to the Cyclones, there are kinks which could be worked out allowing the Mets to keep them as an affiliate in some fashion.
But Kingsport, they’d be as good as gone.
Instead, they could be a part of a “Dream League.” That would be a league of now unaffiliated teams who catch undrafted college players. That’s a fairly steep drop in cache for affiliates like Kingsport.
For example, in 2018 Kingsport had significant prospects like Jarred Kelenic, Ronny Mauricio, Simeon Woods Richardson, and Mark Vientos. This year, Francisco Alvarez and Brett Baty played for Kingsport. That’s a reason to not just go to the ballpark but to also follow the team.
Then again, just having a team in Kingsport, TN is reason to follow the team.
The Cincinnati Reds and Atlanta Braves are nearly five hours away. The Baltimore Orioles and Washington Nationals are over six hours away. Those are the closest options meaning if you want to see a baseball game live your best bet is the Kingsport Mets.
The question is whether Kingsport can continue operations without an affiliation with the Mets and having a roster of players like T.J. Rivera at the point in Rivera’s career where he was a complete nobody with little to no chance of making it to the majors.
Remember, Kingsport needs a new park. While the Mets would help now, that won’t happen if Kingsport is not part of their system two or three years from now.
Where does that leave Kingsport? Well, it likely leaves them on the brink. They need a new ballpark, and with them needing to help pay player salaries in the new “Dream League,” you wonder just how much longer they can continue operations.
If they’re gone, the State of Tennessee has one fewer professional baseball team. The City of Kingsport loses baseball period. That’s a missed opportunity to grow the game in what is mostly football country.
Really, when you look at things, Baseball is the only league without a Major League team in that state. To that end, you’d wonder why baseball would not want to try to find a way to keep fans engaged in that region as much as they possibly can to grow the game.
In the end, this is about punishing players for not being able to afford living off wages below the poverty line. In doing that, Major League Baseball is going to cut its nose off to spite its face.
With billions of $$$$ in MLB, it really is a disgrace that minor leaguers are paid so poorly, especially the majority of whom aren’t signed for big bucks through draft or international signings.
I understand wanting to improve the current minor league systems, but I don’t think eliminating so many opportunities with affiliated ball is the right move. You never know which under the radar future star might not emerge because spots are eliminated. MetsDaddy aptly points out TJ Rivera might never have developed under the new system. With the elimination of many rounds of draft, Mike Piazza might be Mike Who? – rather than Mike Piazza, Hall of Famer.
As for Kingsport, we’ll have to see what happens. I read Kingsport won’t be impacted. Whether that’s accurate or not, time will tell.
Regarding the Brooklyn Cyclones, I strongly, strongly doubt that’s on the chopping block. Prime location, beautiful ballpark, beautiful setting, and very well supported team owned by the Wilpons.
Instead of 3 rookie ball teams, I could see a drop to 2, keeping Kingsport and Brooklyn. The # of games per season could be extended.
Whatever happens, these moves for all big league teams have to be done thoughtfully and fairly – considerations for local communities including rural and small cities across the country who may lose teams.
From what I’ve read and heard, the New York-Penn League is on the chopping block, but teams can move their affiliates to other leagues.