Miguel Batista
At the same time, baseball can be beautiful, and it can be a cruel sport with absolutely no forgiveness whatsoever. When you are discussing pitchers, the highs can reach into the heavens and the lows seem to abut the depths of hell. Perhaps no one knows this better than Jeremy Hefner.
For those unaware, the former Mets pitcher announced his retirement from baseball.
In his announcement on Facebook, Hefner said he was retiring because he needs yet another surgery. This surgery would be to repair a partially torn rotator cuff in his pitching shoulder. Hefner tried rest twice, but it didn’t work. If he is going to continue his career as a baseball player, he will need to have another surgery.
And with Hefner, we learned that surgery isn’t routine. Back in 2013, when seemingly everyone was pushing Matt Harvey to just accept his fate and get Tommy John surgery, Hefner had already decided to have his surgery. He was actually ahead of Harvey in the rehabilitation process. While Harvey was chomping at the bit to try to pitch for the Mets at the end of the 2014 season, it was Hefner who would actually get that chance.
Catastrophe struck. Whatever the cause, whatever the reason, Hefner suffered a stress fracture and a second tear of his UCL, which required a second Tommy John surgery. In baseball today, Tommy John isn’t seen as major reconstructive surgery. Rather, the surgery itself and the rehab required to pitch again is seen as routine. Hefner proved it was anything but.
With Hefner needing a second surgery, the Mets needed to move on. In some sense it was strange seeing the Mets move on from Hefner because he was a player they had coveted. Hefner was twice drafted by the team, but he never signed with them. After he was waived by the Pirates and the Padres in 2011, the Mets picked him up, and they put him on the path to the majors. When Hefner suffered his first UCL, the Mets believed it was worth the $500,000 to keep him around for a season of rehab. But with the second surgery, he was gone.
During this time frame, it was hard to remember all of the high points in Hefner’s career. In fact, Hefner was actually the answer to a trivia question as he had done something in baseball that no one had ever done before.
On April 23, 2012, Hefner made his debut as a reliever in the first game of a doubleheader between the Mets and the Giants. When Hefner entered the game, he was the first ever 26th man on the roster to play in a major league game. In essence, Hefner became the 21st Century version of Ron Blomberg.
The first ever batter Hefner faced was Buster Posey, a player who is one of the best baseball players in the game today. Hefner got Posey to ground-out to shortstop. It was all part of an impressive three scoreless inning relief appearance. Due to the quirks of the 26th Man Rule, Hefner would go back to AAA after the game. It would not be the last the Mets heard from him.
On May 19th, Hefner once again had to enter a game to bail out Miguel Batista. During this five inning relief appearance, Hefner would record his first ever strike out by getting Edwin Encarnacion swinging. On May 24th, Hefner would make his first ever start against the San Diego Padres. Then, on May 29th, Hefner would pitch six strong innings against the reigning NL East Champion Philadelphia Phillies to record his first ever major league win. However, that May 29th game would be remembered for more than just his first win:
During that entire 2012 season, Hefner showed the Mets enough for them to make him a part of their future. In fact, Hefner would be part of the Opening Day rotation. Hefner proved he belonged. In a stretch from April 25th to July 12th, he had made 15 starts going 4-4 with a 2.78 ERA and a 1.053 WHIP. He had a 7:2 strikeout to walk ratio. He was averaging over six innings per start. Especially in a time where Jacob deGrom had yet to establish himself, Noah Syndergaard was in A ball, Steven Matz was dealing with his own Tommy John issues, and Bartolo Colon was an Oakland Athletic, Hefner was showing the Mets he could be a part of this Mets pitching staff over the long haul.
Hefner showed everyone he was a major league pitcher.
While these highs were great, there is one thing that stands out to me about Hefner – his perseverance. After facing the daunting task of having had two Tommy John surgeries, not having thrown a pitch in a major league game in over two years, and with his being released by the Mets, he didn’t give up. He would pitch, and pitch well, in Winter Ball at the end of 2015. He showed enough for the St. Louis Cardinals to sign him to a minor league contract.
While he pitched well through April, the injuries, new and old, began to catch up with him. He would struggle, be released, and now, he finds himself as a retired baseball player. Hopefully, Hefner finds himself a retired baseball player who is proud of all that he accomplished in his career.
Hefner not only got the chance to pitch in the major leagues. It’s all the more impressive when you consider about 30% of fifth rounders even play in the major leagues. Hefner was part of an Opening Day rotation for a franchise known for its pitching. Hefner has not only collected a win, but he also has a home run to his credit. In fact, Hefner did something in the major leagues no one had ever done before.
Overall, Hefner had an all too brief career, but it was a career of consequence. It was a career with highlights. It was a career, he should feel pride in having.