The Gift of the Mets

Seven point five million. That was all. After allowing David Wright to play in one last game, the Mets only had $7.5 million in insurance proceeds for the 2019 season. The accountants went over the numbers three times, but the money remained the same. $7.5 million. Soon, it would be Spring Training.

There was nothing for Brodie Van Wagenen to do put to mortgage the future. So he did.

While Brodie began to toil away, we can look at the home. Citi Field. A ballpark which was helped built by $615 million in public subsidies with $20 million a year coming from Citibank for the naming rights.

In the executive portion of the building was a corner office with a name on the door – Chief Operating Officer Jeff Wilpon.

When the name was first placed there, the team had a top five payroll in the sport. They had a chance to advance up until their final games in each of the past three seasons. Now, after the Madoff scandal, the money was tighter. More creditors. More debt. Less liquidity. He carried this burden as his General Manager entered his office.

As the meeting began, Brodie was looking off in the distance trying to synthesize his thoughts. They each had promised a winner, but there was just $7.5 million in insurance proceeds to spend. He spent all offseason looking for ways to move contracts around, but $7.5 million was just not enough. Every free agent cost more than he expected, and teams wanted more in deals than he anticipated. Being new to the job, he was not quite prepared for that.

Only $7.5 million to build depth, to add a center fielder, mostly just to put this team more firmly in contention. He spent all offseason planning for more, something that would make them the favorites he declared them to be. Something, anything, to justify moving from a lucrative career as an agent to being a General Manager.

During the meeting, Brodie and Jeff took notice of the 2015 pennant banner. They were both very proud of that for different reasons. For Brodie, it was his clients, Jacob deGrom and Yoenis Cespedes, who had played key roles in getting the Mets to that point. It gained both them and himself notoriety.

For Jeff, this was one they did on their own. They survived everything, and they actually went to a World Series. He proved he could oversee a team’s rebuild and come out the other end with a winning team. Nothing meant more to him than that team. He could stand in a room with the Steinbrenners, and he could tell them he built that team from pure guts and guile, which is something they could never accomplish with their free spending ways.

After the meeting was done, with not much headway, each went back to the drawing board to see what they could to to put this team over the top.

Brodie began making phone calls. He knew Robinson Cano had a no trade clause and wanted to come back to New York, and the Mariners wanted to rebuild. He tried and tried again. They asked for Justin Dunn. He wasn’t too keen, but he agreed if they took back Jay Bruce and Anthony Swarzak. They then wanted Jarred Kelenic. He didn’t want to do it, but he wanted to get a World Series for his former clients.

He calculated how he could spend the savings. A catcher like Wilson Ramos. There wouldn’t be room for much more, but they could be better, closer. He pulled the trigger. He was eager for Jeff to come home from safari to tell him the news.

After the deal was done, he began to question himself a little. After all, he just mortgaged the entire future to contend for just two years. He didn’t have the money to address all of the team’s needs. The Braves added Josh Donaldson. The Nationals added Patrick Corbin. The Phillies added Jean Segura, and they were in hot pursuit of Manny Machado and Bryce Harper.

But still, what could a General Manager do with just $7.5 million.

Brodie, who was usually self assured as most agents are, began questioning himself. Instead of boasting what he had accomplished like he had declaring the Mets frontrunners, with Jeff, he was more measured. He really found himself just praying his decision would be met with approval.

Jeff, fresh from safari, popped into Brodie’s office with a bemused look on his face. He was more quiet than usual, which was something Brodie was unaccustomed. He was not ready for that.

Brodie began explaining himself without so much as a question being asked. “Jeff, we actually saved money on the 2019 payroll. Cano is a Hall of Fame talent. Diaz was the best closer in baseball. You wanted to win, and this is the closest we can get to doing it. If I can’t trade for J.T. Realmuto, I can sign Ramos. He wants to be here. We can figure it out from there.”

Jeff just put out his hand, and he shook Brodie’s hand. He gave an assuring pat on the shoulder. Then from inside his jacket pocket, Jeff took out some papers, and he put it upon Brodie’s desk.

“I gave you marching orders, and it looks like you delivered. I am very proud of the job you just did. But if you open that, you will see why I have not been as enthusiastic as you may have thought I would be.”

Brodie unfolded the papers. Initially, there was a wry smile, and then a look of pure shock and horror.

For there was the extension. Due to his role as the General Manager, he could no longer get that extension for deGrom. As an agent, Brodie wanted nothing more than that extension, but due to the conflict of interest, he was not allowed to go and give it to deGrom. He could not even be a part of those discussions.

Brodie exclaimed, “But with the team being better, there will be more fans! There has to be. More fans and more revenues. It’ll happen. I promise.”

Jeff gave that knowing look and just smiled. Both knew the last years of Cano’s deal was going to stop the Mets from giving deGrom any sort of a contract extension, especially with Michael Conforto, Noah Syndergaard, Steven Matz, and Brandon Nimmo soon to follow. They also knew without deGrom going forward, the Mets chances to being relevant into the future was going to be severely compromised.

Jeff just said, “Lets just put this all aside now, order lunch, and let’s talk as friends like we used to do.”

The Mets, as you know, were once run by devoted, passionate, and smart men, who brought the Mets the 1986 World Series. Frank Cashen, Nelson Doubleday, and Fred Wilpon were the first to deliver Mets fans a World Series in the era of free agency. Being wise, not only did they win the World Series, but they had an era of prolonged success like the Mets have never seen before or since.

And here I have told you about two Mets leaders who were not so wise. Each sold something valuable in order to try to win a World Series, and they go in each other’s way. Somewhere, if people will listen, they will tell us they are building the 2019 Mets to be the best team in baseball, and they are smart enough to win for the next decade. They will tell us no matter how much we all doubt.

They are the Mets.

* Adapted from the short story, “The Gift of the Magi” by O. Henry


0 thoughts on “The Gift of the Mets”

  1. Five Tool Ownership says:


  2. OldBackstop says:

    Interesting narrative 😊 A nice read.

    Love Jake, don’t get me wrong. But extending him is not a nobrainer decision.

    To the casual Met fan, after only his fourth year, deGrom might be thought to be 27 or so. But he is 30, we have him for two more years, and his first free agent year we would be gaining would be his Age 33. He is wily, he spots his pitches marvelously, but his velocity will be lower three years from now, and the age curve for pitchers is…..simply a fact. He is highly unlikely to be the masterful workhorse he was this year three years from now.

    Extending him two years early, in the rosy flush of his Cy Young, is a poor poker move, even if you want to paper over the precedent early “reward” extensions leave (see Juan Lagares).

    Fame can be fleeting with starting pitching…look at Madbum’s fade, and he is two years younger than deGrom.

    Of course, we haven’t discussed the length or money of a possible extension, so this is all a fluffy conversation. But deGrom’s age can’t be ignored.

    And, of course, the shock portion of the narrative there is an entertaining McGuffin….everyone knew Brodie would be recused in negotiations with his (past) clients, it was discussed at his introductory press conference.

    So, I don’t see the need for a mad rush to tie up deGrom for his Age 33, 36, or whatever you are envisioning. For one thing, if we go into a fail teardown mode in the next year and a half (we are the Mets) his trade value may be significantly eroded with $80 million (or whatever) strapped on his back.

    1. Five Tool Ownership says:

      Very well said.

      I would assume that all of us would like to see Jake get financial recognition and relative life financial security.

      If he pitches to a respectable 2.50 era what type of arbitration dollars are we taking about in 2019 2020?

      I do believe that when he did have run support he did relax more however getting to a pain free elbow in 2017 did take time. If absent possibly another team would have locked him up. Yet any staff w Harvey, injury or not means walking on egg shells.


      1. OldBackstop says:

        Does it sound callous that I have zero concern about Jake’s financial recognition and security? His clock started late because, right, wrong or indifferent, or in different, he went to Stetson University to play for the Hatters for four years. The Mets carried him though minor league Tommy John. He has already been paid over $12 million by the Mets and will shortly be getting another $12 million (est). The way arb works even if he tanks next year he will be paid another nice tranche (eg: D’Arnaud will get an estimated 3.7 million in this year’s arb).

        I’m more interested in the Mets investing that money for some needed spots in a team we can all enjoy, and maybe Jake can burnish his career with a few 20 win seasons and some postseason glory.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *